Day 303 – Follow that weird idea
…
Follow That Weird Idea: How E.L. Doctorow’s “Desperate‑to‑Write” Trick Can Supercharge Your Creativity
…
Introduction – When the Muse Has Abandoned You
Ever stare at a blank screen, feel the pressure of a deadline, and wonder how you’ll ever produce the next paragraph? You’re not alone. Even literary giants hit the wall.
One of the most celebrated American novelists—E.L. Doctorow—admitted he once felt “desperate to write something.” In that moment he turned to a delightfully odd, almost reckless, technique: grab a random sentence from any book, rewrite it in his own voice, and let the fragment grow into a story.
It sounds bizarre, but the method works like a creative vaccine, inoculating you against writer’s block and stagnation. Below we’ll unpack Doctor’s “weird idea”, explore why it’s effective, and give you a ready‑to‑use, SEO‑friendly action plan to incorporate it into your own workflow.
1. Who Is E.L. Doctorow? – A Quick Primer
| Fact | Detail |
|---|---|
| Full name | Edgar Louis Doctorow (1931‑2015) |
| Famous works | Ragtime, The Book of Daniel, Billy Bathgate |
| Awards | National Book Critics Circle Award, Pulitzer finalist, National Medal of Arts |
| Writing reputation | Known for blending historical fact with fiction, inventive narrative structures, and a “collage” style that pulls from newspapers, songs, and other literature. |
Doctorow’s literary reputation rests on his willingness to play with form. He built entire novels from found text, index‑card fragments, and random juxtapositions—the very ingredients that make his “weird idea” so relevant today.
2. The Weird Idea That Saved Doctorow (and Might Save You)
“I was desperate to write something. I opened a random book, cut out a sentence that struck me, rewrote it in my own voice, and let it become the seed of a whole story.”
— *E.L. Doctorow, interview with The Paris Review, 1978
What He Actually Did
- Picked a random book (often a novel he’d never read before).
- Found a line that felt odd, vivid, or emotionally charged.
- Copied it onto an index card—the original text was never used verbatim.
- Re‑imagined the line: changed tense, perspective, or diction.
- Allowed the altered sentence to “grow.” He kept writing until the new idea was a full paragraph, then a scene, then a chapter.
Why It’s So “Weird”
- It deliberately breaks routine – you’re forced out of your usual theme or genre.
- It introduces a foreign voice that prompts fresh metaphors and structures.
- It turns constraint into creativity – you must work within the limits of the chosen sentence.
The Science Behind the Magic
| Psychological Principle | How It Helps Writers |
|---|---|
| Priming – exposure to unexpected language activates new neural pathways. | You’re more likely to generate novel images and ideas. |
| Creative Constraint – limits focus imagination, forcing originality. | Turns “I don’t know what to write” into “I have a seed to evolve.” |
| Incubation Effect – stepping away from a blank page reduces performance anxiety. | The random sentence gives you something concrete to “hold onto.” |
3. Step‑by‑Step Guide: Adopt Doctorow’s Technique Today
TL;DR: Grab any book, find a random sentence, rewrite it, and let it lead you. Use index cards or a digital equivalent for maximum flexibility.
What You’ll Need
- A physical book (or an e‑book with a “random page” function).
- Index cards or a note‑taking app (Evernote, Notion, Google Keep).
- A timer (Pomodoro 15‑minute intervals work well).
- A pen or keyboard—whatever makes the process feel tactile.
The Process (≈ 10‑15 minutes)
| Step | Action | Tips & Tricks |
|---|---|---|
 Choose Your Source | Pick a book you won’t read for pleasure (e.g., a technical manual, an old travelogue). | The stranger the source, the richer the surprise. |
 Randomize | Open to a random page, or use the “Go to Page” function if digital. | If you land on a page with a picture, skip to the next line of text. |
 Extract a Sentence | Highlight the first full sentence that grabs you. | Look for emotion, vivid imagery, or an unusual word choice. |
 Copy to a Card | Write the sentence verbatim on an index card (or copy into a note). | Keep the original for reference, but don’t use it directly. |
 Rewrite | In 5‑minute bursts, change: • Voice (first → third person) • Tense (past → present) • Key nouns or verbs • Tone (humorous → serious) | Aim for a new sentence that feels yours but still echoes the seed. |
 Expand | Keep writing until you have a paragraph that naturally follows the rewritten sentence. | Ask: What happens next? Who’s speaking? Where are we? |
 Shuffle & Connect | Lay out all your cards (or notes) and shuffle. Look for connections, even if they seem forced. | This is where the collage magic happens—link unrelated ideas to create a fresh narrative. |
 Refine | After 30‑45 minutes, select the most promising thread and draft a full scene. | Remember: the goal isn’t a polished piece yet; it’s a launchpad for larger work. |
Quick Cheat Sheet (Downloadable)
| Card # | Original Sentence | Rewritten | Mini‑Plot Idea |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | “The rain fell in sheets across the cobblestones.” | “Rain hammered the ancient stones like a thousand drums.” | A city dweller discovers a hidden underground market. |
| 2 | “She never trusted the color of the sky at dusk.” | “She doubted the dusk’s violet hue.” | A scientist questions a new atmospheric phenomenon. |
| … | … | … | … |
Pro tip: Keep 10‑15 cards per session. More than that can become unwieldy.
4. Why This Works for Modern Writers, Marketers, and Content Creators
| Audience | Benefit | Real‑World Application |
|---|---|---|
| Fiction writers | Breaks creative ruts, injects fresh voice | Use as a scene starter for a novel or short story. |
| Bloggers & SEO specialists | Generates long‑tail keyword ideas organically | Turn weird sentences into blog post titles that rank. |
| Copywriters & advertisers | Provides unexpected angles for ad copy | A random line can become the hook for a campaign. |
| Educators & students | Encourages critical reading and paraphrasing skills | Classroom activity: “Rewrite a line, then discuss.” |
| Entrepreneurs | Sparks innovation when designing product narratives | Use the method to craft brand stories that stand out. |
SEO Boost
- The technique naturally yields unique phrasing, which Google rewards over generic content.
- Each rewritten sentence can become a targeted heading (H2/H3) that contains long‑tail keywords.
- By linking back to the original source (when appropriate), you strengthen semantic relevance.
5. Real‑World Success Stories
- Natalie, a sci‑fi novelist – After three weeks of “Doctorow cards,” she completed a 70,000‑word manuscript whose opening line—“The moon hung like an over‑ripe lemon over the desert”—was a direct rewrite from a 19th‑century travel guide. The novel topped the Amazon Kindle speculative‑fiction charts.
- Mark, a B2B content strategist – Used the method to generate 30 blog topics in a single afternoon. By extracting sentences from industry whitepapers, he created headlines like “Why Data‑Driven Decisions Feel Like Walking a Tightrope” which increased organic traffic by 42 % over three months.
- Sarah, a UX copywriter – Turned a random line from an old cookbook into the voice of a fintech onboarding flow: “Stir the ingredients until the mixture smooths out” → “Mix your account details until everything clicks.” The onboarding completion rate climbed 18 % after the change.
6. Common Pitfalls & How to Avoid Them
| Pitfall | Symptoms | Fix |
|---|---|---|
| Copy‑cat syndrome – accidentally reproducing the original sentence too closely. | Text triggers plagiarism detectors. | Rewrite at least 30 % of the wording; change perspective, tense, and at least two key nouns/verbs. |
| Analysis paralysis – spending too long choosing the “perfect” sentence. | Timer runs out, you’re still scrolling. | Set a strict 2‑minute limit for the selection step. |
| Over‑reliance on one source – all cards come from a single genre, causing homogeneity. | Your drafts feel repetitive. | Rotate sources each session (novel → manual → poetry → news article). |
| Neglecting editing – treating cards as final copy. | Drafts feel disjointed. | After the “shuffling” phase, spend 20 % of total time editing for coherence. |
7. Frequently Asked Questions (SEO‑Optimized)
Q1. Do I have to use a physical book?
No. Any written material works—magazines, PDFs, Wikipedia articles, even subtitles from movies. The key is randomness and distance from your usual genre.
Q2. Is this technique considered plagiarism?
No. You rewrite the sentence in your own words and use it as a springboard, not as quoted text. Always ensure the final piece is original.
Q3. How many cards should I create per writing session?
Most writers find 8‑12 cards ideal. Enough to generate variety, but not so many that you get overwhelmed.
Q4. Can the method improve SEO rankings?
Absolutely. Unique phrasing, long‑tail keyword generation, and fresh narrative angles all signal value to search engines.
Q5. What if I’m not a novelist—can I still use this?
Yes! The process can be adapted for blog posts, social media copy, product descriptions, lesson plans, and any content where you need a creative spark.
8. Bring It Home – Your First “Doctorow Card” Session (Ready‑to‑Use Template)
Source: __________________________
Page #: ___________________________
Original sentence:
_______________________________________
Rewritten sentence:
_______________________________________
Immediate idea (5‑word hook):
_______________________________________
- Fill out the template within 10 minutes.
- Write a paragraph that follows your rewritten sentence.
- Share your result on Twitter with #DoctorowShuffle and see how others interpret the same seed!
Conclusion – Embrace the Weird, Write With Purpose
E.L. Doctorow proved that desperation can be a catalyst for innovation when you give a weird idea room to breathe. By stealing a line, reshaping it, and treating it as a seed, you:
- Kick‑start creativity with a concrete prompt.
- Introduce purposeful constraints that sharpen focus.
- Generate SEO‑friendly content that stands out in a crowded digital landscape.
Give the method a try tomorrow. Grab that dusty novel on your shelf, pull out a random sentence, and watch the story unfold.
“The best ideas often look like accidents—until you decide to follow them.”
