Your Story’s Lens: A Guide to the Pros and Cons of Every Point of View

Ever read a book and felt like you were right there, inside the character’s head, hearing every thought and feeling every heartbeat? Or maybe you’ve felt like a fly on the wall, watching events unfold with a god-like perspective, knowing secrets the characters themselves don’t.

That shift in experience is the magic of Point of View (POV).

Choosing your point of view isn’t just a grammatical decision; it’s the single most important lens you’ll place on your story. It defines the reader’s relationship with your characters and shapes the entire narrative. Get it right, and your story will sing. Get it wrong, and you can create confusion and distance before the plot even gets going.

So, how do you choose the right lens? Let’s break down the “big four” POVs, exploring their unique strengths and weaknesses.

---

First Person: The “I” of the Storm

What it is: The story is told from the perspective of a character using “I,” “me,” and “my.” We experience everything directly through our senses and biases.

The Advantages:

• Unparalleled Intimacy: This is the gold standard for creating a deep, personal connection. The reader isn’t just watching the character; they are the character.
• A Unique Voice: First-person is the perfect vehicle for a strong, distinct narrative voice. Think Holden Caulfield’s cynical ramblings or Katniss Everdeen’s pragmatic survivalism. The voice is the story.
• Built-in Suspense: The reader knows only what the narrator knows. This is fantastic for creating mystery, as an unreliable narrator can deliberately (or unintentionally) mislead the reader.

The Disadvantages:

• A Limited World: The narrator can only be in one place at one time. If something important happens off-screen, they have to hear about it secondhand, which can feel clunky.
• Risk of Navel-Gazing: Stuck in one person’s head for 300 pages can become claustrophobic. It’s easy to fall into long, repetitive internal monologues that slow the pacing.
• Describing the Narrator: It’s notoriously difficult for a first-person narrator to describe themselves organically without sounding like they’re staring at a mirror.

Best for: Character-driven stories, thrillers, and novels where a unique, memorable voice is key.

---

Second Person: The “You”

What it is: The story speaks directly to the reader, casting them as the protagonist using “you.” It’s rare in fiction but powerful when done well.

The Advantages:

• Total Immersion: This POV drops the reader directly into the action. It’s an active, engaging experience that can feel incredibly urgent and personal. It’s the foundation of “Choose Your Own Adventure” books for a reason.
• Unconventional and Experimental: It immediately breaks the mould and signals to the reader that this is going to be a different kind of story. It can be used to create a sense of disorientation or memory loss.

The Disadvantages:

• Can Feel Gimmicky: It’s a high-risk, high-reward POV. If the reader doesn’t connect with being told who they are, it can feel alienating and pretentious.
• Hard to Sustain: For a full-length novel, the constant “you, you, you” can become exhausting for both reader and writer. It works best in shorter fiction or specific stylistic choices.

Best for: Short stories, experimental fiction, video games, and interactive narratives.

---

Third Person Limited: The Close Third

What it is: The narrator uses “he,” “she,” and “they,” but sticks closely to the perspective of a single character at a time. We see the world through their eyes, feel their emotions, and know their thoughts, but from a slightly more external voice.

The Advantages:

• The Best of Both Worlds: It offers much of the intimacy of first person without the claustrophobia. You also get more flexibility in prose and the ability to describe your protagonist from the outside.
• Creating Dramatic Irony: The narrator can subtly hint at things the character doesn’t yet understand, building suspense for the reader. The Harry Potter series masterfully does this with Harry’s cluelessness about certain plot points.
• Greater Scope: You can switch perspective characters between chapters or scenes, allowing you to show parallel storylines (though you must avoid “head-hopping” within a single scene).

The Disadvantages:

• Can Lack a Strong Voice: It can sometimes feel less distinctive than a strong first person. The narrative voice can blend into the background if not handled with care.
• Head-Hopping Danger: The biggest pitfall is accidentally slipping into another character’s thoughts within the same scene. This disorients the reader and breaks the POV contract.

Best for: The vast majority of commercial fiction, from fantasy and sci-fi to romance and thrillers. It’s the workhorse of modern storytelling.

---

Third Person Omniscient: The All-Knowing Narrator

What it is: The narrator is a god-like entity who knows everything about everyone. They can dip into any character’s mind, travel anywhere in time and space, and offer commentary on the events.

The Advantages:

• Epic Scope: This is the POV for sprawling, epic sagas. Want to show the king on his throne, the soldier in the field, and the assassin in the shadows all in the same chapter? Omniscient is your tool. Think Lord of the Rings or War and Peace.
• Masterful Control: The omniscient narrator can build suspense on a grand scale, weaving together plot threads and creating dramatic irony that the characters themselves could never achieve.

The Disadvantages:

• Can Feel Distant: By jumping between so many heads, it can be difficult for the reader to form a deep, lasting bond with any single character.
• Risk of Info-Dumping: It’s easy for an omniscient narrator to simply tell the reader everything instead of showing them through scenes. This can feel like a history lesson, not a story.
• Can Feel Old-Fashioned: While it’s making a comeback, this POV is strongly associated with 19th-century literature. It takes a very skilled author to keep it feeling fresh and modern.

Best for: Epic fantasies, historical sagas, and stories with a massive cast of characters and sprawling plots.

---

Choosing Your Lens

There is no “best” point of view—only the best point of view for your story. Is your tale an intimate portrait of one person’s struggle? First person might be your answer. Is it a grand, epic battle for a kingdom’s fate? You might need the power of omniscience.

Think about the experience you want to give your reader. Do you want them to be a participant, a close confidante, or an all-knowing observer? Your answer will point you to the perfect lens.

So, experiment. Try writing a scene from two different POVs and see how it feels. The choice is yours, writer. Now, go frame your perfect shot.

What’s your favourite POV to write in, and why? Share your thoughts in the comments below!